Now that I have had a crash course in working at a fine dining establishment, I have done a lot of reading and research on the subject and have come up with a few suggestions for the aspiring diner.
Assuming you are dealing with a well-managed restaurant offering food bestowed from heaven, which is nessesarily my control subject for this digression, the following are a few rules you should have pasted to your foreheads for future reference.
1) If you make reservations, please keep them and show up on time. Patrons have no idea of the amount of work and planning and preparation that goes into executing a well-managed restaurant experience. It requires tectonic geography and complicated timing. Thus, if you have told the restaurant you are coming, they are planning upon you doing what you said you would do. Not only that, if you say you are arriving at eight, they naturally assume you will do so five minutes either side of eight, not an hour later. The well-bred and mannerly use their cellphones if they are stuck in traffic, or they call to say they can't make it. These people rightfully siteth at the right hand of their Maker.
All others will of course rightfully burn their nethers for all eternity.
You see, other people would like to be seated also, and they don't appreciate your table being held for 30, 40 or 50 minutes while you dither like a silly-billy. Get your act together! Put on your big boy/girl pants and look alive and show some spunk!
Even worse than laggards are the large parties who don't show up. No notice, no nothing. They confirmed their reservation as bald-faced as you please, and then they don't show up. Once again, other guests have to wait while an immaculately set table sits there in the middle of the room making a mockery of them in the lobby. In New York they charge you fifty bucks a head if you don't show up. We do that only on big holiday nights because once we were screwed by 50% no-shows. Food has been bought, staff has been scheduled in anticipation, other guests inconvenienced, and for what? Deplorable.
Conversely, arriving a little early always gets you seated almost immediately. I don't know why that is true, it just is.
2) If you and your date have been seated early in the evening, after about 2 hours move the night along to a private room. We had this happen the other night, and it is a phenomenon that is most responsible for people waiting in the lobby. Usually, two people eating can more than adequately absorb the maximum experience to be had in the dining portion of the date in an hour and a half, an hour-forty tops. Valentines night was filled with couples and they were all no longer than this. Its a rule and it just works out that way, partially because it is ungainly to try and mount your date in the restaurant, what with pedestal tables and such, but also because everyone knows it is rude as hell to monopolize a table beyond a certain period without further ordering and paying for your server's time. Later in the evening is fine, but much later and you run into the keeping-everyone-up-past-their-bedtime scenario. So, eat your food, have a good time, bon voyage and please come again.
We had an instance of an early seated couple who arrived promptly at 6:30PM, so good so far, and I allowed them two whole hours before we needed the table again for a table of six, which involved moving tables together. It was a packed night with enough challenges of it's own, but these people put down roots and set up housekeeping for three hours, thus unleashing a contagion of waiting for other patrons, for whom a generous application of comped drinks and appetizers assuaged their discomfort, barely.
3) You have been sat at the best table. This is the most perplexing behavior of all, at least to me. Whenever I am sat at a restaurant, I stay like a good pet. Besides being settled once I've been sat and not wanting to get up again, I assume I was placed there in order to give me the fastest and most convenient service possible for everybody concerned, from me to the waiters to the other guests. And you know what? I have learned I was right.
Personally, I do all sorts of things to assure this. First of all, our main room has no bad tables. It is far from the kitchen and has many interesting nooks and open vistas. I set early arrivals away from each other so they can discreetly converse. I put lovers in secluded places and pretty people in places others can see them so they can show off. Also I am trying to distribute the room evenly so waiters can give the best service possible.
However, there is a species of clientele straight out "The Lucy Show" that thinks we are out to disrupt their carefully balanced feng shui or self-esteem by seating them at what they feel is an inferior table. Now, if someone feels a draft or is claustrophobic or needs more legroom, no request could be more reasonable. Of course you should be accomodated.
However, table-hopping can get to be like knats on a pond surface if a good host isn't careful. We had an epidemic of this one night recently, made all the worse because it involved large tables. One large table changed twice. Have you ever heard of such a thing? We practically had to call Bekins and Mayflower to help with the moving. Another group, well, they just couldn't decide. I personally put together and broke down a six-place table into two four-tops and back again three times. An amused couple on the upper level was very entertained and offered to tip me for my inspired performance of the man who resisted strangling his guests into unconsciousness.
4) If you mistreat people who serve you food, you are fucking crazy. I don't use the f-word often here, so I hope you harken to this.
I would say the way-vast majority of people who leave the restaurant where I work are giddy to the point of irrational exuberance at the fulfillment and conclusion of their dining experience. Its almost spooky. Its like they've been to Disneyland. So I know that when somebody is disatisfied, they are quite probably mentally deranged.
I have never, very honestly, heard of these things happening at our place, I swear to God, but we all have heard of the vile and disgusting things done to the food of patrons who mistreat their waiters. Spitting into the soup is the least of it, so the less said, the better.
Despite this, there is a whole breed that likes nothing more than to bitch because they think it gets them better service, or somehow that it is the only way to get things they erroneously think are being kept from them. These are the same people who call talkradio shows. After they put a poor waiter through the wringer with their abuse, they are also the same people who leave an insulting tip. These folks have consumed alot of waiter spit in their lives, and only God knows what else, believe me.
After abusing her waitress all night at a big table and leaving a lousy tip (of course), one crazy woman pointed her finger at the owner after complaining about what she thought was lousy food and proclaimed that the only thing which would make her happy was a gift certificate for a free meal! I was surprised she wasn't late for a date on a streetcorner because a hustler is a hustler in my book.
As a civilian, I always have been polite and solicitous of my waiter no matter what the situation, and usually by the end of the night they are cutting my food for me and paying ME a tip.
Once again, good manners will get you everything you want in this world, in spades, and with an absolute minimum of effort.
5) Put away the cellphones.
Often I seat people, often a couple, and the moment I inform them who their waiter will be, out whip the cellphones and they begin texting. They don't even relate to each other, let alone me. Very odd.
One woman berated her kids for texting in public whilst waiting in the lobby for the valet. That was going a little far, but hey.
I have noticed very many people who receive cellphone vibrations in the dining room (I rarely hear them ring) will come to the lobby to speak on the phone, or will step outside. That's fitting and proper and very modern of them.
Otherwise, cellphones should be used for letting us know they are stuck in traffic and will be late, or for cancelling reservations, or for telling others in their party to get-a-move-on because their table is being seated. I can often do a traffic summary for the radio because of the mannerly guests who phone-in from all over to tell me of their situations. It's great because I can adjust the room accordingly if I know where people are and when they are coming, that way I can whisk them to a table the moment their dainty feet step inside the door.
6) If you work for a miserably failed and federally bailed-out financial services company, don't go to top-tier restaurants and act like pigs with a sense of entitlement.
I decline to say more at the risk of causing a taxpayer riot in the streets.
In Conclusion ...
So you see, given that the restaurant is doing everything in it's power, the problem really is other people and their deplorably bad manners. So the next time you have to wait an hour for a table, simply ask me who is holding you up, I will ever-so-discreetly and unobtrusively let you know, and when they finally walk out, you can slap them.